10.2 RESOURCE CONSERVATION IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY

1860 - 1920

Listen to Podcast of these Slides

2. John Wesley Powell
  • Report on the Lands of the Arid Region of the United States, 1878.
  • Head of Bureau of Ethnology, 1879-1902.
  • Director of the U.S. Geological Survey, 1881-1892.
  • Lands of arid west: beyond 100th meridian and 20" rainfall line.
3. Powell's Colorado Expeditions
  • First expedition, 1869: Green River through Grand Canyon to present-day Arizona in 4 wooden boats.
  • Second expedition, 1871, scientific survey.
4. John Wesley Powell and Tau-gu, Chief of the Paiutes
  • Learned Indian languages and customs.
  • Gained trust of Indians.
  • Criticized Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) for disregard of Indians.
  • Indians set fires to drive game to trade for goods, but Indians should be removed to control fires.
5. John Wesley Powell
  • Report on the Lands of the Arid Region of the United States, 1878.
  • Irrigated farms: 80 acres if irrigated is enough; lowlands, river valleys; crops.
  • Pasturage farms: 2560 acres if unirrigated is necessary; hilly dry lands; grazing.
  • Timber lands: commercial use and erosion control; high mountains.
  • Cooperative irrigation districts; commons.
6. Reclamation Act, 1902
  • Francis Newlands: Nevada congressman.
  • Bill to implement Powell’s ideas.
  • Irrigation projects in western states by selling public lands.
  • 160 acre irrigated farms; 320 acres for married couples; privileges small farmer.
  • Water from federally funded water projects to 160 acre farms.
  • Bureau of Reclamation: BuRec.
7. Water Law: Rocking Chair Law
  • Riparian rights: English common law.
  • People living on the banks of a river can claim the right to use the water.
  • Right to consume water inheres in land, and is not lost through nonuse.
  • Drink, wash, water cattle.
  • Or, can leave the river alone; sit in rocking chair and contemplate the flow.
  • No right to diminish the flow, e.g. dams.
8. Water Law: Use it or Lose it
  • Appropriation: Appears in England with private property and marketplace.
  • Common law overturned for development; factories, dams, watermills can alter flow downstream.
  • Palmer vs. Mulligan, 1805, New York.
  • Riparian law changed to appropriation to allow private development; profit.
  • Western U.S.: riparian favors ranchers; appropriation favors miners, farmers.
9. Samuel P. Hays
  • Environmental historian.
  • University of Pittsburgh.
  • Conservation and the Gospel of Efficiency (1959).
  • Beauty, Health, and Permanence: Environmental Politics in the United States, 1955-1985 (1987).
10. Bob Marshall
  • 1900-1939.
  • Syracuse University, School of Forestry.
  • 1930s. Head of Outdoors and Recreation Office in the Forest Service.
  • 1933. The People's Forests.
11. Bob Marshall Wilderness
  • 1935. Founds Wilderness Society with Olaus Murie, Aldo Leopold, and Benton MacKaye. Dies 1939.
  • 1940. Bob Marshall Wilderness proposed by the Wilderness Society to commemorate his passion for wilderness.
  • Mountains of northwestern Montana. 1 million acres.
12. Trail Riders

13. Bob Marshall Wilderness

  • Advocated wilderness areas with no roads, timber cutting, or human occupancy.
  • Wanted forests for the poor, camps for the underprivileged, and removal of discrimination against minorities.
14. FDR and Harold Ickes
  • Franklin Delano Roosevelt, 1882-1945.
  • President, 1933-1945.
  • Harold Ickes, 1874-1952.
  • Secretary of the Interior under Roosevelt and Truman.
  • Federal development of electric power.
15. Roosevelt and CCC Camp
  • 1933. Roosevelt establishes Office of Emergency Conservation Work.
  • 1937. Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) created.
  • Relieves unemployment.
  • Promotes conservation.
16. Ford Creek Camp

17. Hugh Bennett

  • Soil Conservation Act, 1935.
  • Soil Conservation Service (SCS), Hugh Bennett, head.
  • Impetus: Dust Bowl of the 1930s.
  • Provides for the control and prevention of soil erosion.
  • Soil Conservation District: Farmers develop their own programs of soil and water conservation.
18. David Brower, 1912 - 2000
  • Executive Director of Sierra Club, 1952-69.
  • Founder, Friends of the Earth (FOE), 1969.
  • John Muir: "If they are to survive, men must learn to be friends of the earth."
  • 1980s. Founded Earth Island Institute.
19. The 1960s:Quality of Life Concerns
  • 1950s-1960s. Air , Food, Nuclear Testing.
  • 1962, Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring. Pesticides.
  • 1964, Wilderness Act. Wilderness Preservation.
  • 1965, Land and Water Conservation Act.
  • 1968, National Wild and Scenic Rivers Act.
  • 1968. Population Bomb, by Paul Ehrlich.
  • 1969, Santa Barbara Oil Spill.
  • 1969, National Environmental Policy Act.
20. Awareness of Environmental Crisis
  • Early 1960s.
  • Stewart Udall, Secretary of the Interior; The Quiet Crisis, 1963.
  • President John F. Kennedy.
  • Senator Edmund Muskie, Chair of Senate Public Works Committee; concerns over pollution.
21. The 1970s: Era of Regulation
  • 1970, Clean Air Amendments.
  • 1970, Occupational Safety and Health Act.
  • 1971, Alaskan Native Claims Settlement Act.
  • 1972, Environmental Pesticide Control Act.
  • 1973, Endangered Species Act.
  • 1974, Forest/Rangeland Renewable Resources Act; Safe Drinking Water Act.
  • 1976, National Forest Management Act.
  • 1976, Toxic Substances Control Act.
22. Signing the Clean Air Act, 1970
  • William Ruckelshaus, Head of the Environmental Protection Agency, Richard Nixon, President, and Russell Train, Chairman of the Council on Environmental Quality.
23. Questions for Discussion
  • Should the forests belong to the people?
  • How can environmental quality best be protected?