Environmental Philosophy and Ethics

11. Ecofeminism

2. EARTHCARE

  • Saving the earth.
  • Women's connections to nature.
  • Why do women do it?
  • How do they do it?

3. Françoise d'Eaubonne

  • 1972: Started Ecologie-Féminisme (Ecology-Feminism Center).
  • 1974: Published "The Time for Ecofeminism" in Feminism or Death.
  • "The planet placed in the feminine will flourish for all."

4. Sandra Marburg and Lisa Watkins

  • Woman and Environment, 1974, Berkeley, Ca

5. Women and Nature

  • Susan Griffin. Woman and Nature: The Roaring Inside Her (1978).
  • Mary Daly. Gyn/Ecology (1978).
  • Links between domination of women and domination of nature under patriarchy.

6. Ynestra King

  • 1976: Taught course on Eco-feminism at Institute for Social Ecology, Vermont.
  • 1980: "Women and Life on Earth: Ecofeminism in the '80s.
  • Conference in Amherst, Mass.

7. Women's Pentagon Action

  • November 17, 1980: 2000 women encircle the Pentagon; block entrances; call for peace.

8. Liberal Ecofeminism

  • Women like men are rational agents.
  • Equal education will allow women to become equals in the workplace.
  • Women can become scientists, lawyers, legislators, and resource managers.
  • Simone de Beauvoir, The Second Sex (1949).
  • Betty Friedan, The Feminine Mystique (1963).

9. Ellen Swallow Richards

  • Meaning of Ecology: house.
  • Ernst Haeckel, 1873, Germany, "oekologie."
  • Ellen Swallow, 1892, introduced "oekology."
  • Ellen Swallow, 1910, used "human ecology" in Sanitation in Daily Life.

10. Rachel Carson

  • 1962. Silent Spring.
  • Pesticides are deadly elixirs.
  • DDT; chlorinated hydrocarbons; organophosphates.
  • Concentration in food chain.
  • Genetic resistance to pesticides.

11. Ecofeminist Perspectives

  • Conference held at USC, Los Angeles, March 27-29, 1987.
  • 25th annniversary of Rachel Carson's Silent Spring.
  • Organized by Gloria Orenstein and Irene Diamond.

12. Cultural Ecofeminism

  • Women and nature have been linked and mutually devalued in Western culture.
  • Sherry Ortner, "Is Female to Male as Nature is to Culture?" (1974).
  • Women's physiology (menstruation, lactation, pregnancy, childbirth); social roles (home care and child care), and psychology (emotions; the personal).

13. Gaia, the Earth Goddess

  • Spirituality, witchcraft, female bodies are source of female power.
  • Celebration of female deities.
  • "Gaia is the ancient earth-mother who brought forth the world and the human race from 'the gaping void, chaos.'" Charlene Spretnak, 1978.
  • "The concept of Mother Earth, . . . or, Gaia, has been widely held throughout history." James Lovelock, Gaia, 1979.

14. Critiques of Cultural Ecofeminism

  • Ecofeminism is essentialist in its conflation of women with nature.
  • "Women's nature is to nurture."
  • "Gaia is a super house-cleaning goddess operating with whiter than white homeostatic detergent" to keep the planet clean. Val Plumwood.

15. Noël Sturgeon

  • Ecofeminist Natures: Race, Gender, Feminist Theory, and Political Action (1997).
  • Problem of biological and ahistorical "essentialism" of women as closer to nature and men as bearers of culture.

16. Love Canal, 1978

  • Lois Gibbs, spokesperson for Love Canal residents.
  • Boarded-up homes in Love Canal, 1980.
  • Hooker Chemical Company plant where the dumping of chemicals in Love Canal began.

17. Helen Caldicott

  • Australian-born pediatrician at Children's Hospital Medical Center, Boston.
  • Author of Nuclear Madness (1978); If You Love This Planet (1992); The New Nuclear Danger (2002).
  • Founder of Women's Party for Survival.

18. Lulu Gant

  • LuLu Gant of Limerick Ecology Action, Pennsylvania, 1980.
  • First anniversary of 1979 Three Mile Island nuclear power plant accident.
  • "Please! Don't let my grandchildren be the last generation!"

19. Carol Barrett

  • Newport, Tennessee.
  • Protest of the polluting of the Pigeon River by Champion International Corporations's paper mill.
  • "Let the Water Breathe." "Let the Pigeon Live."

20. Social Ecofeminism

  • Janet Biehl. "What is Social Ecofeminism?" (1988).
  • Domination of nature stems from domination of human by human.
  • Liberation of women possible by overturning all economic and social hierarchies.
  • Decentralized communities with women as free participants.
  • Women's reproductive, intellectual, sensual, and moral freedom.

21. Janet Biehl

  • Rethinking Ecofeminist Politics (1991).
  • Ecofeminism is fraught with irrational and self-contradictory meanings.
  • Rejects rationality by embracing goddess worship.
  • Rejects scientific and cultural advances because advocated by men.
  • Essentializes women as nurturers.

22. Val Plumwood, 1939-2008

  • Feminism and the Mastery of Nature (1993).
  • Dualisms operate as interlocking systgems of domination.
  • Web of Oppression.
  • The relational self.
  • Environmental Culture: The Ecological Crisis of Reason (2002).

23. Karen Warren

  • "Feminism and Ecology: Making Connections" (1987).
  • "Toward an Ecofeminist Ethic" (1988).
  • "The Power and Promise of Ecological Feminism" (1990).
  • Ecofeminist Philosophy (2000).
  • Dualisms; Power-Over.

24. Ecofeminist Ethics

  • Traditional ethics are grounded in rights, rules, and utilities.
  • Ecofeminist ethics are grounded in care, love, and trust.
  • But are women then complicit in the assumption that women are more caring, emotional, and nurturing than men?

25. Socialist Ecofeminism

26. Socialist Ecofeminism

  • Fulfillment of people's needs not greed.
  • Sustainable relations with nature.
  • Mary Mellor. Feminism and Ecology (1997)
  • Living within the constraints of ecology and biological time.
  • Fulfilling basic human needs for food, clothing, shelter, and energy.

27. Ariel Salleh

  • "Deeper than Deep Ecology: The Ecofeminist Connection" (1984).
  • Domination of nature by man.
  • Domination of women by men.
  • Master-slave role over both nature and women.

28. Ariel Salleh

  • Ecofeminism as Politics: Nature, Marx, and the Postmodern (1997).
  • Socialism, ecology, feminism, and postcolonial struggle can be grounded, unified, and empowered by an ecofeminist dialectic of relations.

29. Chris Cuomo

  • Feminism and Ecological Communities: An Ethic of Flourishing (1998).
  • Ecological feminism as a source of environmental and social ethics.

30. Vandana Shiva

  • Staying Alive: Women, Ecology, and Development (1988).
  • Ecofeminism, with Maria Mies (1993).
  • Nature and women are producers of life.
  • Chipko Movement.